Welcome to our online store. Order online or give us a call at (631) 424-4034.

Custom Cake FAQ

Where do I start?

Creating the perfect cake can be a little overwhelming to some. With so many choices people often ask, “where do I start”? First, we suggest that you browse through our cake galleries to spark your imagination. The next question you have to answer is how many guests you are expecting. After that start thinking about flavors; choose from a variety of cake flavors, icings, & fillings. After you’ve chosen your flavors it is time to let our certified decorator make your cake a work of art.

What size cake do I need?

We have the perfect size cake for any occasion. Click Here to view our serving size suggestions.

How much will my cake cost?

With so many sizes and filling choices it is really up to you! With a variety of both modest and extravagant fillings & decorations, prices can have a wide range. Click Here to see our pricing chart.

Note: pricing given in this chart are base prices. The base prices are determined on a cake with butter cream icing, regular fillings & normal decorations (flowers & an inscription).

What cake flavors are available?

Our standard cake flavors for custom order specialty cakes are a light European sponge cake or a rich, moist chocolate cake. We do also offer other flavors upon special request. Red Velvet, Marble, Carrot Cake, Tres Leches and Napolean are all available in with advanced notice.

Note: Tiered cakes are usually made with our dense pound cake because it is more stable.

What type of fillings and icings can I have?

Reinwald’s has over 20 choices available to fill and ice your cake, most of which are made right here in Huntington. Click Here to view a list of our fillings.

Does my cake have to be refrigerated?

Refrigeration depends on the fillings and icing that you choose and the weather conditions. Please refer to our Filling List.

Will the cake fit in my refrigerator?

We hope so! Click here to view the dimensions of our cakes and cake boxes.

How far in advance do I have to order?

We recommend at least two days notice on all specialty cakes, however we will try our hardest to accommodate all last minute orders. For more detailed cakes please allow a few extra days.

What type of decoration can I have?

Reinwald’s offers choices from the simple and elegant to the extravagant and over the top! Beautiful flowers and an inscription are the standard decoration that comes with the price of the cake. We offer drawings, picture scans, 3-D cut outs and rolled fondant designs for additional charges. Custom decoration can only be done on a 9 inch cake or larger.

Picture Scans - $8.50

Drawings - $12.50 & up

*All other decorations are priced on a cake by cake basis.